Progress

A place to discuss deeper topics

Moderator: Moderators

pkkupo
The Duke of Dope
The Duke of Dope
Posts: 1761
Joined: Wed Jun 21, 2006 1:12 am
Location: Minnesota, USA
Contact:

Progress

Post by pkkupo »

(Progress concerning the sustainability and efficiency of overall, global human wellbeing and enrichment)

To ask succinctly, what does it mean to you, and how should it be sanctioned? As far as I'm concerned, the only kind of progress that truly matters (when talking in terms of the human race as a whole) is scientific and technological progress.

Some people, (thoughtful/smart people) think that breakthroughs in tech and science are a waste of time and money, especially in rough economical times. Others (again, smart, thoughtful people) think that scientific research (namely, exploration of the cosmos and experimentation of that which has already been discovered) is necessary to find new ways to, and improve methods of creating energy and manipulation of resources. But of course, this involves a high degree of risk. Especially because we think we have already uncovered so much on and around our world. I believe history shows us that exploration and observation of the universe and of our more immediate world begets efficiency of manipulation and overall understanding of our world, as well as space and the universe around us... So what do you guys think? Do we stop funding NASA, UKSA, Fermi, and other space/science agencies and just spend on and exploit what we know? Or do we keep looking for more wondrous worlds and perhaps more unknown, sustainable and efficient ways to benefit our, as well as other, earthly species?
Last edited by pkkupo on Sun Jun 27, 2010 1:29 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image
Like all dreamers, I mistook disenchantment for truth...
Bubbles
The Green Bastard
The Green Bastard
Posts: 4357
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 2:10 am
Location: Canada
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by Bubbles »

well personally i feel as though technology has fucked us more than it has helped us, turning the earth into a barren wasteland with all of them toxicities created by it.

humans were supposed to be as in tune with nature as every other animal, and for no reason should we be in the state we are.

I M O
Image
pkkupo
The Duke of Dope
The Duke of Dope
Posts: 1761
Joined: Wed Jun 21, 2006 1:12 am
Location: Minnesota, USA
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by pkkupo »

"Should" is a bad word in my opinion... I'd prefer to hear "Want to, because..."


Think of the fact that I'd have never known you guys at all were it not for vehement tech research and advancement.... As well as the strong intrinsic desire for efficient global communications and networking...

Think also of this: Natural selection selected us. We, as a species, have arbitrary control of the fate of this planet. Do you really think it's appropriate to hang out in forests, plains and deserts as other animals do without giving our all at understanding, as best we can, ways to not only develop our knowledge of all things physical and improve our quality of life, but to understand and research what is, ultimately, our real world? (The universe) When we have the cognitive capacity to do so?

I think it's almost our duty (and as history shows, our intrinsic penchant) as citizens of the universe to figure out how and why things do the things they do and how to make things do what we want them to do...

Particle physics, astro-physics, chemistry, bio-chemestry, ... Why do these thing hold such prominence in human society if it is not natural for our species to be curious about such things?
Image
Like all dreamers, I mistook disenchantment for truth...
Bubbles
The Green Bastard
The Green Bastard
Posts: 4357
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 2:10 am
Location: Canada
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by Bubbles »

it IS natural for us to be curious, that is our nature. however i believe that technology has not progressed us as humans.

personally i feel as though hospitals, although helpful are preventing natural selection, causing our evolution to slow down to a near stop.

natural selection should never be put on hold, or else you end up with an extreme overpopulation which ends up eating up the earth's resources causing us to die out...

gnome'sayin?
Image
Weedguru_Falkon
King of Kannabis, God of Ganja
Posts: 1690
Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2005 7:59 am
Location: Stoned Soliloquy
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by Weedguru_Falkon »

A slight tangent, if I may to begin.
Would everyone not agree that a fairly decent and accurate definition of "cancer" is something that replicates out of control? Cancerous cells are simply something that doesn't have a termination sequence, so the cluster just keeps growing--exponentially-- to get larger and larger.
That being said:

Humans are simply cancer, yes? The earth is a living thing and we are a form of cancer living on it, our population growing exponentially.
Now, there are only two outcomes for this, as far as I can tell, and they are these: Either the host dies, in which case cancer cannot survive for it has nothing to feed off of, or cancer dies yielding life to the host.

Either way, cancer dies. Natural selection, no natural selection, it's not going to matter soon. As you said PK, hospitals are definitely allowing us to be more destructive, to live longer, to consume resources at a faster rate than should be.

Having said that, should we continue to explore? Well, it is in my personal philosophy to believe that humans aren't going to last forever. I'm a firm believer that something will happen in 2012, however this may be irrelevant. Point being, it doesnt matter how much we're going to learn, it's not going to keep our civilization around forever. We have too polluted our minds to continue in the way we have in the last few centuries. Our species is one of pure destruction and hate, greed, love of power. Perhaps, just maybe, 2012 is going to be an enlightenment and these shall cease to plague the cognitive bipedal species; I don't really know if we can count on that now.

The more we seem to "learn" about nature, about laws, physics, rules, the more we find out that we know less. Hell, who's to say that what we think we know is even at all right? Some things that we have come to prove on our own soil, on our own host of a planet, may not be at all true in another area of the universe (hell, maybe even multiverse). Other species in the universe/multiverse may have had a different way of advancement and have found out much more than we know now.

So, is it beneficial to keep "progressing," to keep trying to learn about the area around and encompassing us? ... For our amusement, maybe, but the universe will always prevent its secrets from being known, for it is far more omniscient than we could hope to be.
Image
Ikku wrote:I personally don't find it to taste plasticy, I think it tastes good. Like fractally flowery hyperspace.
logically
The Duke of Dope
The Duke of Dope
Posts: 1564
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 2:41 am
Location: the woods
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by logically »

Bubbles wrote:it IS natural for us to be curious, that is our nature. however i believe that technology has not progressed us as humans.

personally i feel as though hospitals, although helpful are preventing natural selection, causing our evolution to slow down to a near stop.

natural selection should never be put on hold, or else you end up with an extreme overpopulation which ends up eating up the earth's resources causing us to die out...

gnome'sayin?
yes.

I think humans are just trying to pretend to be something they are not....
ImageA warrior may choose pacifism, all others are condemned to it.Image
Weedguru Higher
Tetrahydrocannabinologist
Tetrahydrocannabinologist
Posts: 14620
Joined: Sun Mar 30, 2003 1:31 pm
Location: Canada
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by Weedguru Higher »

As much as I would like to participate in this conversation, I can't I don't understand much...

These words are just not in my vocabulary...
pkkupo wrote:sustainability , succinctly, sanctioned, cosmos
Image
Ricardo
Casual toker
Casual toker
Posts: 61
Joined: Sat Mar 27, 2010 3:58 am
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by Ricardo »

the whole 2012 thing isnt the end of time its the end of and age, astrologically speaking. we are going to shift from the pisces age to the next one. i think.
Bubbles
The Green Bastard
The Green Bastard
Posts: 4357
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 2:10 am
Location: Canada
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by Bubbles »

Ricardo wrote:the whole 2012 thing isnt the end of time its the end of and age, astrologically speaking. we are going to shift from the pisces age to the next one. i think.
no thats year 2150, the 2012 bullshit is.. well... bullshit
Image
weedguru_animal
Ganja God
Ganja God
Posts: 6562
Joined: Tue Jul 16, 2002 6:07 pm
Location: south
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by weedguru_animal »

The pursuit of, and protection of, Money and Power drive most research in the contemporary world.

(Progress concerning the sustainability and efficiency of overall, global human wellbeing and enrichment)
is a hippy ideal, which has no substance in the Now.

Its not hard to look at the intense advances we have made in all sciences, then to look at the world and ask the question, then find the answer to, 'have we made the world a better place?'.

The disparity between the rich and priveliged and the poor and abused has never been so severe, globally. And I am solely looking at humanity. For its a given, that the non human world has suffered hugely more than it has benefitted by our 'progress' as a species. Evolution eh...not often for the better when it comes to our species. Do the Strong survive and the Weak die off??? Depends how you apply the terms Strong and Weak. For a CEO of a major pharmaceutical company sees the world in $$$$$, not blood, not heart, not passion. For the kingpins of DARPA have zero interest in 'global human well being and enrichment'....as two small, but important examples. Their interests are financial, territorial, not altruistic.

This is a massive subject, which demands much more time than I can presently give, but I will return...
pkkupo
The Duke of Dope
The Duke of Dope
Posts: 1761
Joined: Wed Jun 21, 2006 1:12 am
Location: Minnesota, USA
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by pkkupo »

^I very much understand that money and power is the way the world is run, Animal. I'm not talking of our immediate and irreversible systems of government or economics. And as such, I have little interest in such things. I'm talking of science. Human life is a scientific process. A learning process. We are doomed to have many egregious problems because of our imperfections. We are eventually doomed to fail altogether by the very nature of life and the universe. I'm not talking about elitism, propriety, or money in any sense save for perhaps discussing government spending concerning scientific research and exploration. I'm not looking for anything concerning broad, perpetual human conflict. I'm talking of nothing but scientific discovery, exploration, and exploitation.

^^I'd love to hear an explanation, Logic, if you feel inclined to elaborate...
Weedguru_Falkon wrote:Humans are simply cancer, yes? The earth is a living thing and we are a form of cancer living on it, our population growing exponentially.
Now, there are only two outcomes for this, as far as I can tell, and they are these: Either the host dies, in which case cancer cannot survive for it has nothing to feed off of, or cancer dies yielding life to the host.
Well, no. I think that's a rather unfair comparison. Cancer is causes by the rapid, unstoppable mutation of cells. We evolved over millions of years. Cancer cannot be controlled. Cancer also has no consciousness or conscience. We are different in that, whether or not we are all aware of it, we can make choices and take steps to preserve our host.

As you said PK, hospitals are definitely allowing us to be more destructive, to live longer, to consume resources at a faster rate than should be.
Flyin' said that, actually, and is more or less unrelated to this discussion...

I'm a firm believer that something will happen in 2012
Why?

--------

I must quote Carl Sagan here...

"We live in a society exquisitely dependent on science and technology, in which hardly anyone knows anything about science and technology."


You cannot deny this truth. And on top of that, we must take into account the fact that science and tech related to the sustainability of our species is steadily becoming more and more complex and diverse almost out of sheer necessity. And it is because of that necessity that we must become more efficient in engineering. Like you said, there's probably more shit out there than we will ever be aware of, and perhaps some that we are not yet aware of but have the capability to discover, and hand over to our engineers so they may exploit it efficiently.

The more we seem to "learn" about nature, about laws, physics, rules, the more we find out that we know less.
This notion does not excite you? And yet we've also learned so very much.

Hell, who's to say that what we think we know is even at all right? Some things that we have come to prove on our own soil, on our own host of a planet, may not be at all true in another area of the universe (hell, maybe even multiverse). Other species in the universe/multiverse may have had a different way of advancement and have found out much more than we know now.
A "multiverse" is wild conjecture from fantasy physics. Let's work with what we have. And hey, we've observed galaxies and planets and stars that are BILLIONS of LIGHT-YEARS away following the same rules of gravity and light speed, etc. The laws of physics, as far as our generation ever need be concerned, are universal. However, I'll admit that there may be physical forces at work out there that we have yet to experience or notice.
So, is it beneficial to keep "progressing," to keep trying to learn about the area around and encompassing us? ... For our amusement, maybe, but the universe will always prevent its secrets from being known, for it is far more omniscient than we could hope to be.
True, but think of this for a second... We have discovered useful things in this universe just by observing and studying it. We've discovered elements just by observing what frequencies of light are being absorbed by the gas that it shines through (elements like helium and nitrogen) ... We know more about the universe than you might think. Think about this also... If we had stopped exploring and exploiting discoveries before the 1900s, we wouldn't have penicillin, many vaccines, we wouldn't be able to genetically engineer food (which is a good thing), and the list goes on.
Image
Like all dreamers, I mistook disenchantment for truth...
Weedguru_Falkon
King of Kannabis, God of Ganja
Posts: 1690
Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2005 7:59 am
Location: Stoned Soliloquy
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by Weedguru_Falkon »

pkkupo wrote:
Weedguru_Falkon wrote:Humans are simply cancer, yes? The earth is a living thing and we are a form of cancer living on it, our population growing exponentially.
Now, there are only two outcomes for this, as far as I can tell, and they are these: Either the host dies, in which case cancer cannot survive for it has nothing to feed off of, or cancer dies yielding life to the host.
Well, no. I think that's a rather unfair comparison. Cancer is causes by the rapid, unstoppable mutation of cells. We evolved over millions of years. Cancer cannot be controlled. Cancer also has no consciousness or conscience. We are different in that, whether or not we are all aware of it, we can make choices and take steps to preserve our host.
Why?
Image
That shows a pretty steep, and seemingly exponential growth of our species. It will not stop. You think that we will "make choice," conscious choices at that, to curb this? With our technology, we're adding longevity to people and preventing diseases that normally comb through populations to thin them out and keep them in balance.
some numbers...
Year Population
1 200 million
1000 275 million
1500 450 million
1650 500 million
1750 700 million
1804 1 billion
1850 1.2 billion
1900 1.6 billion
1927 2 billion
1950 2.55 billion
1955 2.8 billion
1960 3 billion
1965 3.3 billion
1970 3.7 billion
1975 4 billion
1980 4.5 billion
1985 4.85 billion
1990 5.3 billion
1995 5.7 billion
1999 6 billion
2006 6.5 billion
2009 6.8 billion
2011 7 billion
2025 8 billion
2050 9.4 billion
Hopefully that formats correctly. Thats a goddamn steep number curve. It will not slow down. That right there is exponential growth. That is what a "mutated" cell does when it becomes cancer. I see very little distinguishment other than that we are a sentient species who tries to imagine we are differen.t
People wont stop having sex, or prevent having kids just because the world is getting populated. What was the last idea that billions of people truly adhered to?...... ....... I'll wait.
As you said PK, hospitals are definitely allowing us to be more destructive, to live longer, to consume resources at a faster rate than should be.
Flyin' said that, actually, and is more or less unrelated to this discussion...
For the reason and argument stated above.

I'm a firm believer that something will happen in 2012
Why?
Because I have lost faith in humanity's nature to care and to be able to have a harmonic relationship with the earth.

Also, because college is expensive and if 2012 happens, I won't have to be in debt :P
[/joke]

--------
I must quote Carl Sagan here...

"We live in a society exquisitely dependent on science and technology, in which hardly anyone knows anything about science and technology."


You cannot deny this truth. And on top of that, we must take into account the fact that science and tech related to the sustainability of our species is steadily becoming more and more complex and diverse almost out of sheer necessity. And it is because of that necessity that we must become more efficient in engineering. Like you said, there's probably more shit out there than we will ever be aware of, and perhaps some that we are not yet aware of but have the capability to discover, and hand over to our engineers so they may exploit it efficiently.
Acknowledged.

The more we seem to "learn" about nature, about laws, physics, rules, the more we find out that we know less.
This notion does not excite you? And yet we've also learned so very much.
It does excite me. I love science. Just something I'd figure I should throw out there.

Hell, who's to say that what we think we know is even at all right? Some things that we have come to prove on our own soil, on our own host of a planet, may not be at all true in another area of the universe (hell, maybe even multiverse). Other species in the universe/multiverse may have had a different way of advancement and have found out much more than we know now.
A "multiverse" is wild conjecture from fantasy physics. Let's work with what we have. And hey, we've observed galaxies and planets and stars that are BILLIONS of LIGHT-YEARS away following the same rules of gravity and light speed, etc. The laws of physics, as far as our generation ever need be concerned, are universal. However, I'll admit that there may be physical forces at work out there that we have yet to experience or notice.
Yes, this is true. I think we gad an argument with blackxs way back in the day about all this. I'm not trying to prove something, merely just saying its very much a possibility.

To deny a possibility is perhaps the most naive thing we can do. two hundred years ago, if I told you "Hey, in the future, we'll have a way to communicate instantly with people on the other side of the world, while being able to hear them and see them! and you'll be able to get anywhere in the world in a matter of hours, or a day at most."
They would laugh in your face and tell you to get the fuck out.


We have discovered that our solar system behaves very, very erratically compared to other solar systems out there. Whereas our gas giants areflung to the edges of the solar system, and the denser rocky planets are nearer the center here, in other systems it is exactly opposite, and more and more systems tend to behave in that way rather than our own. We have yet to figure out why, and it doesn't seem to play with the physics we have come to know.
And dark matter/energy? That doesn't play with our physics either. Beyond that, what about trying to find a unifying theory or ... relativity, i suppose. Physics that govern small matter dont play by big matter rules, and vice versa. Anyway, i digress.
So, is it beneficial to keep "progressing," to keep trying to learn about the area around and encompassing us? ... For our amusement, maybe, but the universe will always prevent its secrets from being known, for it is far more omniscient than we could hope to be.
True, but think of this for a second... We have discovered useful things in this universe just by observing and studying it. We've discovered elements just by observing what frequencies of light are being absorbed by the gas that it shines through (elements like helium and nitrogen) ... We know more about the universe than you might think. Think about this also... If we had stopped exploring and exploiting discoveries before the 1900s, we wouldn't have penicillin, many vaccines, we wouldn't be able to genetically engineer food (which is a good thing), and the list goes on.
You are right, and again I'd like to perhaps step off to a slight tangent if we may.

Going back to the 2012 thing and why I don't think humanity should/will stick around...
The last true vaccine to be invented/discovered way polio, Jonas Salk in the 1950s, correct? The ONLY reason we don't have vaccines and cures these days is simply money. The global consciousness of greed and a desire for money keep peoples welfare from them. Odd, though, since we are trying to discover other ways to promote longevity. Anyway, take this as my basis...
Company X can manufacture a cure for.. I dunno, say HIV, and sell it to a single patient for $20,000. Thats a one time payment for their troubles. If Company X can create a treatment, at $5,000 a year, for the patients entire life, hell, they have a lot of income from many places for pretty much as long as the virus sticks around. Being humans, of course theyre going to follow the money.

This is why a cure for cancer and HIV, among many other things, hasn't been put out there, I think.

Progress will benefit some, yet not others. I ask of you this.
With all of our current technology, if a solar storm occurred that wiped out all telecommunications, all networks and all digital technology, modern humans would be fucked. 3rd world humanity would be rather untouched. I suppose this could be a cleansing, and that demonstrates our weakness that we have grown to suck on the supple nipple of technology to a state of frenzied abuse and addiction.
Image
Ikku wrote:I personally don't find it to taste plasticy, I think it tastes good. Like fractally flowery hyperspace.
SpRi7e
Ganja God
Ganja God
Posts: 5208
Joined: Sun Sep 17, 2006 5:48 am
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by SpRi7e »

now I don't believe in any of that 2012 bullshit, but I agree with you on that if you think in a BIGGER sense that we are all a type of cancer on earth. Even consciously speaking, we are not able to control how much/fast we reproduce to the extent of being able to stop it with EXTREMELYYYY invasive destruction
Peace Not Greed.
Weedguru_Falkon
King of Kannabis, God of Ganja
Posts: 1690
Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2005 7:59 am
Location: Stoned Soliloquy
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by Weedguru_Falkon »

A bigger sense? Tell me, how exactly can you define bigger? We live on the smallest speck of dust in the universe. We are not big at all.
Image

So... your post seems a bit... inaccurate?
Image
Ikku wrote:I personally don't find it to taste plasticy, I think it tastes good. Like fractally flowery hyperspace.
pkkupo
The Duke of Dope
The Duke of Dope
Posts: 1761
Joined: Wed Jun 21, 2006 1:12 am
Location: Minnesota, USA
Contact:

Re: Progress

Post by pkkupo »

^No joke. It's been like this for months now.

Image

Anyway, I need more time for a more thoughtful post. Gimme a day or two.
Image
Like all dreamers, I mistook disenchantment for truth...
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users