The 3rd and 4th Dimension

A place to discuss deeper topics

Moderator: Moderators

AbbyRoad
Ganja God
Ganja God
Posts: 4340
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 12:09 am
Location: Sarnia
Contact:

The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by AbbyRoad »

Have you ever seen a 3-D movie? i thought the effect was pretty weak but some people seem really impressed. some of those impressed people respond by saying how awesome it would be to see a movie in the 4-D. And that just fucking bothers me so much.

the way i understand it is the the 3rd Dimension is depth and volume. The 1st and 2nd being a point in "space" and the line between, respectively.
The 4th Dimension would be Time. not like hours days or months but the concept of passing time which forced us to make up systems in which to organize our actions in the 3rd Dimension.
So really...every movie we see is in the 4th Dimension.

the only cool 4-D movie idea would be getting the entire film played instantly inside your brain

sorry if this doesnt make sense or sounds incrediably stupid
to really explain what i mean i would first have to explain exactly what connectations im giving to the words im using
and frankly, im way to lazy and burned out now
Image
Mate
Chess Expert
Posts: 3434
Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2006 12:58 pm
Location: Desrever os
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by Mate »

hmm, i don't see time as a dimention, i see time as a measuring system.
time is one of the 7 fundamental physical quantities, but not a dimention
at a subatomic and atomic level there is no difference between the past and the future.
we're into subatomic substance, we're just too evolved and huge to feel it.

i don't think we can see the 4th dimention.
we're 3d living in a 3d world.
our eyes actually only see in 2D. Our retina has only a 2D surface area with which it can detect light coming into our eye. What our eye sees is in fact not 3D, but a 2D projection of the 3D world we are looking at.
Because of our mind and evolved brain, we can mentally reconstruct what we see in 3d, from 2D images.
It does this by using indirect information in the 2D images like light and shade, parallax, and previous experience.

our retina doesn't actually see 3D depth, we instinctively infer it. we have a good idea of what 3D is, to the point that we are normally quite unconscious of the fact we're only seeing in 2D

so i think, a hypothetical 4D being would have a 3D retina, and would see the 4D world as 3D projections
phheeww.

is there even a 4th dimention ?
Last edited by Mate on Thu May 27, 2010 10:37 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"In Life, everyone starts out as a pawn, Every journey begins with a single move. . It's the decisions we make along the way that shapes our endgame."
J O E
Bonghead
Bonghead
Posts: 281
Joined: Tue Apr 06, 2010 3:55 pm
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by J O E »

there are 10 dimensions
its just there in the air
Mate
Chess Expert
Posts: 3434
Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2006 12:58 pm
Location: Desrever os
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by Mate »

you get that from that movie with lines and dots ?
"In Life, everyone starts out as a pawn, Every journey begins with a single move. . It's the decisions we make along the way that shapes our endgame."
pkkupo
The Duke of Dope
The Duke of Dope
Posts: 1761
Joined: Wed Jun 21, 2006 1:12 am
Location: Minnesota, USA
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by pkkupo »

J O E wrote:there are 10 dimensions
I thought there were only miracles and magic... :lol:


It's common conjecture amongst super-string theorists that there are definitely more than three dimensions of space because there are not enough dimensions to describe the physicality of certain phenomenon concerning strings. The math only works with 10 dimensions of space, and one dimension of time. Don't ask me how the math is done, I have no idea... So, if you were to view a film in "4D" you would be viewing the first four dimensions of space, which humans are incapable of doing.... You are constantly experiencing the dimension of time, which is intimately related to the many dimensions of space, but isn't one of the supposed ten dimensions. I'll explain...


Any dimension of space beyond the three that we can see is simply curled up into the smaller folds of the first three. So it makes sense that Mate would say that we can only "infer" the third dimension. It is the hardest to experience. The first two are cake. For example, if you're looking at a pencil from 50 meters, it's likely that your brain is only able to physically interpret two dimensions. Therefore, as far as your brain is concerned at that particular moment, there are only 2 dimensions to the pencil, when in actuality you are able to experience three.


We are imperfect and limited by our senses, and therefore cannot "see" or experience every dimension of space no matter how close we get.
Image
Like all dreamers, I mistook disenchantment for truth...
J O E
Bonghead
Bonghead
Posts: 281
Joined: Tue Apr 06, 2010 3:55 pm
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by J O E »

fucking dimensions... how do they work?

DMT allows you to see other dimensions I heard and yea mate of course I got 10 dimensions from that video its fucking awesome!
its just there in the air
User avatar
Dr. Greenthumb
Stoned Immaculate
Stoned Immaculate
Posts: 8112
Joined: Sun Aug 03, 2003 8:17 pm
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by Dr. Greenthumb »

So a truly 3-D movie wouldn't have the dimension of time. The movie would either be a moment long or a longer movie would have to be instantaneously absorbed and comprehended in a moment, without time passing.

You should check out this flash video if you haven't seen it already...
http://www.tenthdimension.com/

Mathematically speaking there's over 10 dimensions. I feel like if we just keep working our way up will find the dimension that is "god". Some kind of being that exists in and comprehends all these different dimensions.

I'm fascinated by different dimensions and I love having stoned discussions about the subject, thanks abby.
“Cannibalism? Racism? Dude, that’s not for us ... those decisions are better left to the suits in Washington. We’re just here to eat some dude!”
-Charlie Kelly
Bubbles
The Green Bastard
The Green Bastard
Posts: 4357
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 2:10 am
Location: Canada
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by Bubbles »

i think they call it 3-D in movies solely because it pops out and sounds cool.

not using the actually definition, but their own version of it.
Image
AbbyRoad
Ganja God
Ganja God
Posts: 4340
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 12:09 am
Location: Sarnia
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by AbbyRoad »

i love getting stoned and talking about dimensions of reality, among other things
ever since i had my morning glory trip in high school i have been utterly convinced that reality is made up of "dimensions" that are literally layered onto of each other. building blocks that bring more richness and texture to reality as they settle.
like mate and pkkupo were saying we are only able to experience the dimensions that our senses can detect. but using math, logic and critical thinking 10 dimensions were defined
i saw the video a while ago and thought it was insightful and easy to understand.

but lets get back to the subject of the 4th dimension
i guess calling it time was the wrong word.....its really more of a concept which is intimately related to time.
i thought/felt that the 4th dimension was like...the continual wave-length of reality. when all possibilities exist. almost circular
outside of time, yet all time
we invented "time" (hours, minutes, seconds) in order to organize this open circular space, you know.....record data and set up dates
the 5th dimension would be Probability?

lets hug this out
(im serious, its been a year since i graduated college and im missing those philosophy classes so much. i feel like im getting stupider)
Image
Bubbles
The Green Bastard
The Green Bastard
Posts: 4357
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 2:10 am
Location: Canada
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by Bubbles »

^ its alright, you cant get any stupider :P lol jk :lol:
Image
AbbyRoad
Ganja God
Ganja God
Posts: 4340
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 12:09 am
Location: Sarnia
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by AbbyRoad »

:rastasmoke:
Image
Mate
Chess Expert
Posts: 3434
Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2006 12:58 pm
Location: Desrever os
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by Mate »

i have difficulty with that string theory and m theory that proposes 10-11 dimensions.

The whole space that is everywhere (wich isnt the limit of 'another space) has three dimension, and that space can't really have more dimension if you take the general logic that more than 3 lines can't intersect at right angles on one point. it can't be proved from situations or concepts, but our intuition is based on this and it's demonstrably certain.

If there's extra dimentions, they're definitly spacial, we can't feel em, and there's never been any physicial experimens that has comfirmed the reality of these additional dimensions. the only possible ways is if the space act as if it's curled up in extra dimentions on subatomic scale, like, at the string level, or below.
But yea. it's hard to imagine or to conceive.

That'S why i say i have diffculty with the 10-11 dimention theories. They seem to be true, but they're impossible to explain or to feel. Exept with mathematics. and even there, it's hypotetical.
"In Life, everyone starts out as a pawn, Every journey begins with a single move. . It's the decisions we make along the way that shapes our endgame."
pkkupo
The Duke of Dope
The Duke of Dope
Posts: 1761
Joined: Wed Jun 21, 2006 1:12 am
Location: Minnesota, USA
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by pkkupo »

^You definitely have a valid point when it comes to describing the location of any given object/particle. Three dimensions would seem like enough, yea?.... That's why it's such an intriguing theory. Our senses are feeble and pathetic when it comes down to it. We would like to believe otherwise, but the truth of the matter is, there is a myriad of physical forces at work in the universe that we are either unaware of because we cannot experience them, are unable to understand, or to proud to admit exist. When thinking of dimensions, think of my pencil example, Mate. It's all about perspective.


The hadron collider may be able to all but prove the existence of a more-than-3D spatial universe. We know what should happen when two particular particles collide at near-lightspeed. We know what such a collision should result in, and what should be left over after such a collision...... Super-string theorists conjecture that these particles will not be detectable after the collision not because the particles are so small, but because they will then exist in the minuscule folds of the dimensions that we are unable to experience.
Image
Like all dreamers, I mistook disenchantment for truth...
Mate
Chess Expert
Posts: 3434
Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2006 12:58 pm
Location: Desrever os
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by Mate »

pkkupo wrote:Our senses are feeble and pathetic when it comes down to it. We would like to believe otherwise, but the truth of the matter is, there is a myriad of physical forces at work in the universe that we are either unaware of because we cannot experience them, are unable to understand, or to proud to admit exist. When thinking of dimensions, think of my pencil example, Mate. It's all about perspective.
but it does not help me to grasp the concept in wich, something would litterally stop existing in our visual / physical dimensions to go in another.

it isnt complicated to build higher dimensional worlds using the Einstein equations. But WHY SHOULD WE CARE????

It's because physicians dream of a global theory: a single and simple mathematical equation in which all fundamental forces and forms of matter can be described together in a way that is internally consistent and consistent with current and future observation.
And it turns out that having more than 3D in space makes it possible to build such a theory.
Extra dimensions in string theory

Strings theory is a possible global hypothesis of all fundamental forces, but it requires a 10 dimensional spacetime, or bad quantum ghosts with unphysical - unprobable negative chances and probabilties become part of the spectrum, wich creates a HUGE problem in d=10 string theory. How to get the d=3 world as we know it out of the theory.
there's some explanations to this, but they're hard to conceive, once again..
pkkupo wrote:Super-string theorists conjecture that these particles will not be detectable after the collision not because the particles are so small, but because they will then exist in the minuscule folds of the dimensions that we are unable to experience.
the only 2 explanations that could maybe help me a bit to conceive and ''see'' it all are the kaluza klein compactification and the braneworlds theories.

KK compactification merges up the extra dimensions into some very tiny but interesting spaces of their own.
you'd need to read about it, cause it's hard to explain.. especially with my limited english.
it should interest you anyway.

Braneworlds makes the extra dimensions HUGE, but constrain all the matter,gravity, light, time, to propagate in a three dimensional subspace called the three brane.
(a good example is your tv screen that could be said to be a two brane of three dimentional space.)
my observed four dimensional spacetime(including the ''duration'') is like the tv screen, a subspace of some bigger space that we can't feel cause all matter are constrained to move on our subspace...
The hadron collider may be able to all but prove the existence of a more-than-3D spatial universe.
i can't wait to see how the LHC experiments will turn out, if it shows evidences of the string theory, it proves there's more dimensions, it won't really help to see em, but it will prove they exist.....
but then.. we will have to know how many D's there is exactly..
because depending of the type of the string theory.... it varies from 10 to 26, :|

abby wrote:but lets get back to the subject of the 4th dimension
i guess calling it time was the wrong word.....its really more of a concept which is intimately related to time.
i thought/felt that the 4th dimension was like...the continual wave-length of reality. when all possibilities exist. almost circular
outside of time, yet all time
we invented "time" (hours, minutes, seconds) in order to organize this open circular space, you know.....record data and set up dates
the 5th dimension would be Probability?
Duration is the good word.
Einstein said duration could be shown as a 4th dimentions because it gives more precision about a location of any given object in space. (h,w,d + t)
there's a close relation between probabilities and dimensions,

about the probabilities.
Physcisits and philosopher of physics sees probabilities as dimensionless, like ''a limit of relative frequencies'' as the sample size gets bigger.

whatever if something is a dimension or not depends on how important it is most of all, not on whether it is measured quantitatively as a ratio of two things ( Quantity, and ''what you're measuring )
all dimensions in physics fits to a fundamental quantity at same time (like a category such as mass, time,length, etc.) and to a numerical valued quantity. Incidentally, the non-frequentist approaches to probability do not require probability to be
regarded as generally limits of relative frequencies.

(took me like.. around an hours to type this post.. hope you understand it, i had time to listen that whole stuff.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlSfVA92808)
"In Life, everyone starts out as a pawn, Every journey begins with a single move. . It's the decisions we make along the way that shapes our endgame."
AbbyRoad
Ganja God
Ganja God
Posts: 4340
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 12:09 am
Location: Sarnia
Contact:

Re: The 3rd and 4th Dimension

Post by AbbyRoad »

mate
you just made my head explode
imma think this over for a bit, then get back at it
Image
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users