Depression
Moderator: Moderators
-
Grrrl
- Moderator
- Posts: 1220
- Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 12:19 pm
- Location: Manchester, uk
- Contact:
Depression
For years me and my Dad have had an ongoing debate about whether depression is an actual illness or if it is just a state of mind. Suffice to say there is an equal amount of quantative and qualative data to support both theories, to the point where I am unsure now where I wholly stand on the topic.
My Dad suggests that throughout life you will experience a full spectrum of emotions, including happiness, anger, sadness, loneliness, etc at some point, and that it is natural to feel these emotions, and thus is against the idea of treating depression with drugs like SSRI's which regulate certain chemicals in your brain (mainly seratonin, occasionally dopamine/norapinephrine). Also he points out that the success rate for anti-depressants is little better than that of a person given a placebo drug, and that it makes someone dependent on a drug to control their moods/emotions rendering it more difficult to stop taking them. Which I would tend to agree with. My Dad tends to believe that depression is a state of mind, and that you can pull yourself out of it without drugs or therapy, but that most people would rather get sympathy and wallow in their own self pity than admit responsiblity over their own life. However I am not so sure that everything is quite that black and white.
I see the mind and brain as separate, the brain being one of the most major organs in your body, whereas I see the mind as being made up of your life experiences, how you percieve them and how they shape you. With this in mind, If you have a headache and take a paracetamol to relieve the headache, it is not a lack of paracetamol that caused the headache in the first place, despite it helping aid in relief. The same goes for depression, anti-depressants like prozac are taken to treat depression by boosting seratonin levels but that doesn't mean the depression was caused by depleted/insufficient levels of seratonin. I think it is not entirely clear whether seratonin levels in the brain are the cause or effect of someone suffering from depression. However if it appeared to be a cause I think it would just be one factor out of many thing combined, I don't think a chemical imbalance would be enough to cause it on it's own. There is evidence to suggest genetics can aid in causing depression, you're almost twice as likely to develop depression if your closest of kin also suffer the disease, although that could also be down to sharing the same/similar environment and upbringing.
My Dad suggests that throughout life you will experience a full spectrum of emotions, including happiness, anger, sadness, loneliness, etc at some point, and that it is natural to feel these emotions, and thus is against the idea of treating depression with drugs like SSRI's which regulate certain chemicals in your brain (mainly seratonin, occasionally dopamine/norapinephrine). Also he points out that the success rate for anti-depressants is little better than that of a person given a placebo drug, and that it makes someone dependent on a drug to control their moods/emotions rendering it more difficult to stop taking them. Which I would tend to agree with. My Dad tends to believe that depression is a state of mind, and that you can pull yourself out of it without drugs or therapy, but that most people would rather get sympathy and wallow in their own self pity than admit responsiblity over their own life. However I am not so sure that everything is quite that black and white.
I see the mind and brain as separate, the brain being one of the most major organs in your body, whereas I see the mind as being made up of your life experiences, how you percieve them and how they shape you. With this in mind, If you have a headache and take a paracetamol to relieve the headache, it is not a lack of paracetamol that caused the headache in the first place, despite it helping aid in relief. The same goes for depression, anti-depressants like prozac are taken to treat depression by boosting seratonin levels but that doesn't mean the depression was caused by depleted/insufficient levels of seratonin. I think it is not entirely clear whether seratonin levels in the brain are the cause or effect of someone suffering from depression. However if it appeared to be a cause I think it would just be one factor out of many thing combined, I don't think a chemical imbalance would be enough to cause it on it's own. There is evidence to suggest genetics can aid in causing depression, you're almost twice as likely to develop depression if your closest of kin also suffer the disease, although that could also be down to sharing the same/similar environment and upbringing.

Me importa un pimiento...
-
SpRi7e
- Ganja God

- Posts: 5208
- Joined: Sun Sep 17, 2006 5:48 am
- Contact:
Re: Depression
I'm fully confident in saying that I believe there are two different types of depression. Sure there is depression where it's basically all mental and people just over exaggerate things. There are pessimists through habit that see the world in a more depressing way, that's a good way to show that it's mental. Now the difference between THAT and major depression, is that their highs aren't as high..but their lows are WAY lower than ours. Where out of nowhere, for no reason.. they basically feel less than worthless to the world and have no emotions towards anything anymore temporarily. THAT is a chemical imbalance and I've seen first hand in certain people that even though with as much help and support that their body just won't let them get out of it. Major depression isn't just in the head, it's the body physically not letting you get out of that stage. That's what major depression is, where there is VERY little that you can do about it. Sure it's also part mental, but that's only a smaller percent on the reason why they are depressed.
The reasons why SSRI's and MAOI's suck donkey dick for 'depression' is that the people don't like the way their mind works while on them. Especially for the people who have minor depression where it isn't proven to be an actual imbalance. They aren't helping getting over problems by taking the drugs, in fact...it can even make it worse for them, upsetting their mental structure causing more chaos in their head. They don't learn to cope with situations because they are in a different mindset..and once off the drugs, your mindset changes back to what it was for the most part... making the way you 'coped' with it on the drug have a different response than without. People go on and off of their medications thinking that maybe it's gone, or that they feel better off the medication so they won't get it again. WRONG! it comes back, going on and off those meds are HORRIBLE, and I've read a LOT of stories on it happening that way and from a lot of people I've talken to.
I do believe that minor depression is bullshit and it is mostly through their mind that they are being depressed. In which case to fix, you would need to learn to handle situations better yourself or have cognitive behavior therapy sessions to get out of that mindset you keep falling back in to.
The reasons why SSRI's and MAOI's suck donkey dick for 'depression' is that the people don't like the way their mind works while on them. Especially for the people who have minor depression where it isn't proven to be an actual imbalance. They aren't helping getting over problems by taking the drugs, in fact...it can even make it worse for them, upsetting their mental structure causing more chaos in their head. They don't learn to cope with situations because they are in a different mindset..and once off the drugs, your mindset changes back to what it was for the most part... making the way you 'coped' with it on the drug have a different response than without. People go on and off of their medications thinking that maybe it's gone, or that they feel better off the medication so they won't get it again. WRONG! it comes back, going on and off those meds are HORRIBLE, and I've read a LOT of stories on it happening that way and from a lot of people I've talken to.
I do believe that minor depression is bullshit and it is mostly through their mind that they are being depressed. In which case to fix, you would need to learn to handle situations better yourself or have cognitive behavior therapy sessions to get out of that mindset you keep falling back in to.
Peace Not Greed.
-
wgToonces
- Sir Toke-a-lot

- Posts: 2777
- Joined: Wed May 04, 2005 8:57 am
- Location: Glasgow, Scotland
- Contact:
Re: Depression
Without having read it: Just a state of mind!
Now to actually read it.
To add to what Sprite said.. There are two types of depression. One where it's basically in your head, the other when it's physically fucking you up and holding you back. I wonder why or if this is actually realised. If it is actually realised then there should be help groups where this is all explained and how it can all be in the head and something simple like a positive outlook could change the way they feel. Show them how to have a positive outlook etc. But then it gets down to shit like wether or not "they" "want" everyone to feel good or not.
Goddamn I'm retardedly baked. Don't really know if any of that made sense. But there's my take of it as of now.
There should be physical help. Not pills that fuck your brain up.
Now to actually read it.
To add to what Sprite said.. There are two types of depression. One where it's basically in your head, the other when it's physically fucking you up and holding you back. I wonder why or if this is actually realised. If it is actually realised then there should be help groups where this is all explained and how it can all be in the head and something simple like a positive outlook could change the way they feel. Show them how to have a positive outlook etc. But then it gets down to shit like wether or not "they" "want" everyone to feel good or not.
Goddamn I'm retardedly baked. Don't really know if any of that made sense. But there's my take of it as of now.
There should be physical help. Not pills that fuck your brain up.
:scratchs:
-
Bubbles
- The Green Bastard

- Posts: 4357
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2010 2:10 am
- Location: Canada
- Contact:
Re: Depression
i dont really have an opinion here as this topic is very boring to me, however i would like to say something you probably have already said to your dad, Rasta.
there is more to depression than the depression itself, there is the cause. if somebody has a very important person to them die, or any thing of equivalent shittiness (loss of legs, stroke, etc) the person deserves atleast a few months of wallowing around in tears.
however if the cause is something stupid like.. you realized you have to work your entire life.. well fuck you then.
and on the topic of medication. I will put my thing in the style of a pokemon battle for the gameboy.
You gain depression
you have been prescribed shit
...
several months later
...
you go to the doctor
you explain you feel better and want to quit the pill
you quit the pill
youre even more depressed because your brain is used to having work done for it, rather than doing it itself.
gnome'sayin?
there is more to depression than the depression itself, there is the cause. if somebody has a very important person to them die, or any thing of equivalent shittiness (loss of legs, stroke, etc) the person deserves atleast a few months of wallowing around in tears.
however if the cause is something stupid like.. you realized you have to work your entire life.. well fuck you then.
and on the topic of medication. I will put my thing in the style of a pokemon battle for the gameboy.
You gain depression
you have been prescribed shit
...
several months later
...
you go to the doctor
you explain you feel better and want to quit the pill
you quit the pill
youre even more depressed because your brain is used to having work done for it, rather than doing it itself.
gnome'sayin?

-
Weedguru_Fire_Inside
- Sir Toke-a-lot

- Posts: 3686
- Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2004 1:03 pm
- Location: England
- Contact:
Re: Depression
i agree with bubbles.
apart from the work for the rest of your life shit, there's no way i'm doing that, lol.
although i believe most people who say they are depressed, are not clinically depressed, just down in the dumps, i do believe there are people out there with very imbalanced personalities and mentalities who could definitely be depressed due to mayube chemical imbalances in the brain? or anything of the sort.
what pisses me off about depression is not those who suffer from it, but those who view everything in life as depressing for no reason.
apart from the work for the rest of your life shit, there's no way i'm doing that, lol.
although i believe most people who say they are depressed, are not clinically depressed, just down in the dumps, i do believe there are people out there with very imbalanced personalities and mentalities who could definitely be depressed due to mayube chemical imbalances in the brain? or anything of the sort.
what pisses me off about depression is not those who suffer from it, but those who view everything in life as depressing for no reason.
Death is the only certainty. EVERYTHING else is variable.
-
JokersAce
- The Duke of Dope

- Posts: 1388
- Joined: Tue May 29, 2007 5:00 am
- Contact:
Re: Depression
LIFES A BITCH AND THEN YOU DIE
When the going gets weird, the werid turn pro.
HOW CAN SO MANY YEARS COME TO PASS WITHOUT ANYONE TELLING ME I SPELLED WEIRD WRONG?
HOW CAN SO MANY YEARS COME TO PASS WITHOUT ANYONE TELLING ME I SPELLED WEIRD WRONG?
-
Certified-Nutter
- The Iron Lungs of Wales!

- Posts: 1835
- Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2006 7:27 pm
- Location: somewhere in the vallies
- Contact:
Re: Depression
so fuck the world and lets get high :pJokersAce wrote:LIFES A BITCH AND THEN YOU DIE
<- My old account-
Mate
- Chess Expert
- Posts: 3434
- Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2006 12:58 pm
- Location: Desrever os
- Contact:
Re: Depression
in some sort of ways, i don't really believe in depression.
i think people creates the physical depression themselve falling into a downward spiral of unhapyness, and that state of mind totally drains your serotonin..
Your subconscious is way more powerfull than you think and has a huge impact on all your body, on every cells of it.
When you start to feel depressive - it is not because of your body, it's because of your mind, something wrong is going and you may not want to talk about it, consciously ignore it, or just don't have anyone to talk with about it.
AntiDepressors(or whatever or you call em) are useless. They will cure you filling your serotonin gland with artificial you and let you believe that your unhealthy state of mind is... healthy, because your brain is drugged.
YOU need to go trought it, tell yourself life is far from over, and you got to solve every shit that pisses you off in life in some sort of way - otherwise, it will always strike you back
You will tell me, EASIER SAID THAN DONE.
yes, in facts, it is.
my 2cents.
i think people creates the physical depression themselve falling into a downward spiral of unhapyness, and that state of mind totally drains your serotonin..
Your subconscious is way more powerfull than you think and has a huge impact on all your body, on every cells of it.
When you start to feel depressive - it is not because of your body, it's because of your mind, something wrong is going and you may not want to talk about it, consciously ignore it, or just don't have anyone to talk with about it.
AntiDepressors(or whatever or you call em) are useless. They will cure you filling your serotonin gland with artificial you and let you believe that your unhealthy state of mind is... healthy, because your brain is drugged.
YOU need to go trought it, tell yourself life is far from over, and you got to solve every shit that pisses you off in life in some sort of way - otherwise, it will always strike you back
You will tell me, EASIER SAID THAN DONE.
yes, in facts, it is.
my 2cents.
"In Life, everyone starts out as a pawn, Every journey begins with a single move. . It's the decisions we make along the way that shapes our endgame."
-
Grrrl
- Moderator
- Posts: 1220
- Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2003 12:19 pm
- Location: Manchester, uk
- Contact:
Re: Depression
I agree with your beggining and I like the sentiments towards the end, but as you said it is much easier to say than to do. I mean, you can work through things to a point, but not every problem that crops up in life can be rectified by just positive thinking, and things that happened in the past cant be changed nor can the impact they have/had on you. I suppose prehaps some people have less effective methods of coping for one reason or another, be it nature or nuture. I found out recently that there are people who endure music or art therapy as a means to helping them deal with depression, as it helps them to express themselves in a way that feels less forced and less on the spot than having counselling. It apparently has a higher rate of success than anti-depressants and councelling from what research I have performed on the web. I do however remain fairly sceptical.Mate wrote:in some sort of ways, i don't really believe in depression.
i think people creates the physical depression themselve falling into a downward spiral of unhapyness, and that state of mind totally drains your serotonin..
Your subconscious is way more powerfull than you think and has a huge impact on all your body, on every cells of it.
When you start to feel depressive - it is not because of your body, it's because of your mind, something wrong is going and you may not want to talk about it, consciously ignore it, or just don't have anyone to talk with about it.
AntiDepressors(or whatever or you call em) are useless. They will cure you filling your serotonin gland with artificial you and let you believe that your unhealthy state of mind is... healthy, because your brain is drugged.
YOU need to go trought it, tell yourself life is far from over, and you got to solve every shit that pisses you off in life in some sort of way - otherwise, it will always strike you back
You will tell me, EASIER SAID THAN DONE.
yes, in facts, it is.
my 2cents.

Me importa un pimiento...
-
Mate
- Chess Expert
- Posts: 3434
- Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2006 12:58 pm
- Location: Desrever os
- Contact:
Re: Depression
Therapies may be good - as long as they do not involve chemical medicamentions - wich ruins the mass population's health.
I think most of modern diseases and viruses are due to over-medicamentation and tests they had to do with them... anyway
I also just think anyone who starts feeling unhappy and cofused should ask himself questions, instead of panicing in his/her mind losing controll of his/her emotion and body controll.
In fact - i ask myself question every minute in my life to help me doing the best choices about where to go, what to do, or whatever when i'm confused - i ask myself questions.
I already know the answers subconsciously, but i can't figure them out of nothing. I consciously don't know em yet.
Someone that starts to feel depressed obviously don't know the root of it all. Psychologist will help you to get there, Anti-depressant will let you believe life is all right - you get out of it easily yourself if you truly want to stop feeling like shit.
When the problem that makes your mind fucked up will be solved - your serotonin gland will start fillin again and you will feel normal - your blood pressure will come back to normal , you will stop feeling shrinked within yourself.
I think most of modern diseases and viruses are due to over-medicamentation and tests they had to do with them... anyway
I also just think anyone who starts feeling unhappy and cofused should ask himself questions, instead of panicing in his/her mind losing controll of his/her emotion and body controll.
In fact - i ask myself question every minute in my life to help me doing the best choices about where to go, what to do, or whatever when i'm confused - i ask myself questions.
I already know the answers subconsciously, but i can't figure them out of nothing. I consciously don't know em yet.
Someone that starts to feel depressed obviously don't know the root of it all. Psychologist will help you to get there, Anti-depressant will let you believe life is all right - you get out of it easily yourself if you truly want to stop feeling like shit.
When the problem that makes your mind fucked up will be solved - your serotonin gland will start fillin again and you will feel normal - your blood pressure will come back to normal , you will stop feeling shrinked within yourself.
"In Life, everyone starts out as a pawn, Every journey begins with a single move. . It's the decisions we make along the way that shapes our endgame."
-
(weedguru)scarf
- Ganja God

- Posts: 5762
- Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2005 12:50 pm
- Contact:
Re: Depression
the very end of your text rasta made me think..Grrrl wrote: There is evidence to suggest genetics can aid in causing depression, you're almost twice as likely to develop depression if your closest of kin also suffer the disease, although that could also be down to sharing the same/similar environment and upbringing.
My best friends mum has suffered from depression for as long as we have been mates... and thats been a good 15-16 years..
When on her medication she is very very happy and bubbly person (but not to the point that everything is always good and everything is optimistic...) I have only seen her once off medication and she is very unhappy person.... my friend said that he has seen her in the car in their driveway crying for hours... it may have something to do with the environment (she was the predominant bread winner, and money was often tight... or tighter than they were used to).
My friend has also suffered, and it was brought into an almost psychosis state when a long term girlfriend broke up with him.
So is this genetics or again can it be blamed on the notion of environment and circumstance?
The kicker is that he has a twin brother whom i am also very close to. He has never had any disposition towards depression, despite effectively accomplishing very little thus far in comparison to his brother.
There are too many unknowns for us to make any definite statements about depression and the way it works.
And yes i do think there are perhaps multiple forms of depression. in the same way there are multiple forms of cancer- they cant all be treated in the same manner.
woah
-
cutthecashflow
- Intellecutally Wasted

- Posts: 7747
- Joined: Sun Aug 03, 2003 8:19 pm
- Location: Home of the Sioux!
- Contact:
Re: Depression
Depression is a real disease that is charactarized by repeated neuronal firing that causes a sort of rewiring in the brain that can be cured/treated with a wide variety of different medications/treatments. While it is treatable and sometimes curable many people will fall back into a major depressive episode in their lifetimes and if they have had 3 major depressive episodes in the past they are almost %100 guaranteed to have more throughout their life.
Although the term depression is vague because there are in fact multiple types of depression all of which can be treated in different fashions. Major Depressive Disorder, Seasonal Affective Disorder, Manic Depression, Bipolar, Dysthmic Disorder, Post Partum Depression, Anxiety Depression, Atypical Depression, Chronic Depression, Double Depression, Endogenous Depression, Situational/Reactive Depression, Agitated Depression, Melancholic Depression, Catatonic Depression.
Cognitive behavioral therapy has been shown to be effective, as have tricyclics, MAOIs, SSRIs, and in some cases stimulants (dexidrine). Although I don't necessarly folllow one clear path or another when it comes to treating this disease I do believe that this is an actual illness characterized by abnormal levels of neurotransmitters in the brain caused by repeated exposure to certain events that propel an individual into a gloomy and miserable existence.
Although the term depression is vague because there are in fact multiple types of depression all of which can be treated in different fashions. Major Depressive Disorder, Seasonal Affective Disorder, Manic Depression, Bipolar, Dysthmic Disorder, Post Partum Depression, Anxiety Depression, Atypical Depression, Chronic Depression, Double Depression, Endogenous Depression, Situational/Reactive Depression, Agitated Depression, Melancholic Depression, Catatonic Depression.
Cognitive behavioral therapy has been shown to be effective, as have tricyclics, MAOIs, SSRIs, and in some cases stimulants (dexidrine). Although I don't necessarly folllow one clear path or another when it comes to treating this disease I do believe that this is an actual illness characterized by abnormal levels of neurotransmitters in the brain caused by repeated exposure to certain events that propel an individual into a gloomy and miserable existence.
Get busy living or get busy dying.
-
cutthecashflow
- Intellecutally Wasted

- Posts: 7747
- Joined: Sun Aug 03, 2003 8:19 pm
- Location: Home of the Sioux!
- Contact:
Re: Depression
^That's an extreme case Dan, depression can also come from an onset of just feeling not yourself for a prolonged period of time and eventually it gravitates to a further dimension. So in essence one could think of it as laying on a spectrum with your example at the far extreme end and mine on the other. Either way there are varying degrees and I think a doctor would recommend intense psychiatric care in your example far beyond being medicated. In a sense in certain situations there is not much that can be done, but in others there is, just as in any realm of life.
Get busy living or get busy dying.
-
weedguru_animal
- Ganja God

- Posts: 6562
- Joined: Tue Jul 16, 2002 6:07 pm
- Location: south
- Contact:
Re: Depression
mate...i was still blind drunk this morning when I fell out of bed and wrote the above, hence its almost complete lack of reason! I will get back to this intriguing debate, when the mist has cleared from my eyes and mind.
-
flagg
- Bonghead

- Posts: 281
- Joined: Wed Aug 11, 2010 7:44 am
- Contact:
Re: Depression
My daughter was killed in a car accident when she was 2 months from her 21st birthday .. ever since ive been like the clown with the smiley face but crying inside .
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users