Page 1 of 2

Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 1:21 am
by weedguru_waffles
The 41 year-old had been in a relationship with a man whom he lived with and told officials “it would make me feel happy” for it to continue.

But his local council decided his “vigorous sex drive” was inappropriate and that with an IQ of 48 and a “moderate” learning disability, he did not understand what he was doing.

A psychiatrist involved in the case even tried to prevent the man being given sex education, on the grounds that it would leave him “confused”.

Mr Justice Mostyn said the case was “legally, intellectually and morally” complex as sex is “one of the most basic human functions” and the court must “tread especially carefully” when the state tries to curtail it.
But he agreed that the man, known only as Alan, should not be allowed to have sex with anyone on the grounds that he did not have the mental capacity to understand the health risks associated with his actions.

read the rest here: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/ ... g-sex.html

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 4:35 am
by Bubbles
too stupid to fuck... jeeze this guys got it bad.

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 7:18 am
by sugarstalker
is... how.... can they do that?!? I mean... what?

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 10:52 am
by WeedGuru_Flow
Yeah who the hell are they to do that ?

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 3:21 pm
by zERo~Chronic
Is it rape if they are too dumb to say no?

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 6:38 pm
by WeedGuru_Flow
haha, you sick bastard :p

No but I don't understand how someone who apparently is véry active when it comes to sex has to be restricted like that.

Did he rape women ? Does he not understand the concept of 'it has to be consensual' ?

It's all so vague. Health risks ? If he uses protection that won't be much of a problem,even if he's retarded I can't imagine it would be much of an effort to get a rubber on him... (no homo)

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Thu Feb 10, 2011 9:21 pm
by AbbyRoad
huge violation of human rights going on here

sex and libido is one of our most primal instincts (check out andrias animal sex muesum thread lol)
to tell a man, even with severe mental disabilities, that he cannot participate in consensual sex acts is robbing him of.....well...some goddamn intangible thing.
whats the next step here, chemical castration to make sure he cant have sex? or if we have the technology in the future disabling the part of the that creates sexual impulse and desire? i shudder to think of these things happening to another innocent human being.

and its bullshit that they would actually go about and prevent him from getting sex education. sure he may not benefit from it as much as someone with fuill cognitive functions, but goddamn it cant hurt to TRY explain STI's, condoms, and consent. the excuse that it will leave him confused it just weak...im sure sex itself was confusing at first, but the guy seemed to get an understanding of it.

and you know what else gets my goat about this? he has an actual medical reason he cant understand the risks sex posses. unlike all the other plain stupid people in the world that practice unsafe sex. get STI's and KNOWINGLY pass them on to unsuspecting partners.

the only possible reason i can see for banning someone from having sex is to prevent them from being sexually abused by someone trying to take advantage of their mental disabilities. but that doesnt even really make sense. its the other persons mental issue creating damage

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Fri Feb 11, 2011 2:19 am
by weedguru_waffles
uhmmm abby I'd have t disagree. It's not a violation of the human right (according to the code at least :p) And yeah even though it is very primal... i guess they figure there are other ways of getting the "release". But on the other hand, this ruling is rather ridiculous... I think there could have been a better way to deal with the situation. Plus, monitoring his activity of whether or not he's having sex is pure absurd!

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Fri Feb 11, 2011 3:03 am
by AbbyRoad
just because laws say its not a violation of human rights doesnt mean it isnt

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Fri Feb 11, 2011 3:09 am
by weedguru_waffles
well... yeah. the human rights code deals with the interaction between the government and people... to be exact though mainly within businesses.... and jobs and your rights which are protected by the code within that range... and not so much of people dealing with people, where this case is dealing between person and another person. In fact, the Charter of rights & freedoms would apply to this if anything. It grants your fundamental freedoms, however these freedoms can be infringed which depends if it is in the best interest for the person. Ie. if you have some religious right that don't allow you to transfer blood... yet there is an 8 year old kid who's going to die if there isn't a blood transfusion done... than this would be considered to be for a better cause than "respecting your religion"... (btw, this is also stated in the charter)
He lived in a home provided by the council, where he developed a sexual relationship with a man called Kieron by the court. Alan was also accused of making lewd gestures at children in a dentists’ surgery and on a bus, although no police action was taken.
soo after reading this paragraph, I think it's in the public's interest and benefit that he was banned. I guess it's in a way better than sitting in jail... no?
However, the fact that he was restricted to be with his "partner" is kinda stupid because no where does it say that his partner had any mental incapacities, thus he can make informed decisions on whether he'd like to proceed with the sexual intercourse or not.... But then again, that's kinda like taking advantage of the mentally incapable person right? I guess I can see this case from both sides... hm.

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Fri Feb 11, 2011 9:17 pm
by wgToonces
I'm stayin outta this one :lol: Don't even want to have to think about this.

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Sat Feb 12, 2011 12:41 am
by Bubbles
wgToonces wrote:I'm stayin outta this one :lol: Don't even want to have to think about this.
same here man im going to let it stand as a hilarious article.

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 11:14 am
by (weedguru)scarf
just to piss people off...

make him get a vasectomy and then let him have all the sex he wants

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Wed Feb 16, 2011 2:59 pm
by weedguru_waffles
looool^ but that doesn't eliminate std's :p

Re: Court bans man with low IQ from having sex

Posted: Thu Feb 17, 2011 3:19 am
by AbbyRoad
plenty of people with the intelligence to understand sti's choose not to wear condoms