Page 1 of 2

Is god good

Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 5:00 pm
by Slim_Joules
i have been thinking that if there was no higher power who showed us the difference between good and evil then then no one would be evil all would be good like by giving us rules to live by it shows us how to be evil and how to be good but with no rules in the first place we would not be evil

Posted: Thu Mar 16, 2006 8:36 pm
by Tokin42
The only way for this to be possible would for humans to be like machines, like animals acting only on instinct. You would not have a consciousness, no sense of self, because with consciousness comes choices and a human (with a conscious) will eventually make an "evil" choice or decision.

Without evil there is no good. Its all about balancing the yin and yang. I also think that whatever higher power is out there, is playing a game with us. "Let's give them a conscious and see what happens" kinda thing

Posted: Thu Mar 16, 2006 9:22 pm
by Dr. Greenthumb
The only way for this to be possible would for humans to be like machines, like animals acting only on instinct. You would not have a consciousness, no sense of self, because with consciousness comes choices and a human (with a conscious) will eventually make an "evil" choice or decision.
I think humans are more like machines when they dont rely on instinct. The basic human cycle know seems to be 'consume and die' that seems much more mechanic to me than anything you might do relying on instinct.

Posted: Thu Mar 16, 2006 10:52 pm
by Tokin42
hmm thats true. thats pretty much the rule for all animals though, "consume or die", i guess we are actually becoming more primitive and..egotistic

Slim, what you're proposing has been tried by many governments: fascism.
Weedguru DrGreenthumb wrote:humans are more like machines when they dont rely on instinct
i meant that without a conscious people won't do creative things, and be satisfied by just acting on instinct. Youre right, the conscious of "good" and "evil" is much like an animal thinking "good food" "bad food."

Posted: Fri Mar 17, 2006 7:07 am
by Dr. Greenthumb
By 'consume and die' I mean the way that society is today. You want new things so you work to buy new things you do this till you die and it's an endless cycle.

Posted: Fri Mar 17, 2006 11:27 am
by weedguru tom
i work to buy nice shit to fill my life with material happieness, as you said above eat, sleep, mate, repeat.

Posted: Fri Mar 17, 2006 1:17 pm
by weedguru_animal
yeh but Tom you think......you think with a fair amount of power..and you are aware of your Self....i know that even though we've never met eye2 eye..

going back to the first post: what higher power is it which/who shows you the difference between Good and evil???And importantly, when have you witnessed this divine differentiation (good/evil)??????

Evil is a man made word as is Good.though the concepts i'm sure are shared by other creatures..Or is it beyond belief for some/many that a sparrow could be happy or sad, a penguin depressed and wallowiing in icy pols of self pity after being dumped by his lady penguin,,,a lady seahorse staying with her belvoed male seahorse for the duratiom of her life and upon her death he vows never to sleep with another.....Or how about a pissed off fly..he has seen bits of food allday, but every time he was about to chuck his putrid acid a wasp came in to steal the catch! Trees and plants also, im sure they have some kinda Self , like every organic lifeform on the planet(and on others no doubt)..

Only a truly mindless creature can accept the ideas of Right and Wrong from others 100%..True Pros learn as they go..But generally I think every creatue is born with a innate hidden or visible sense of what is Right and what is Wrong...

Society is geared towards keping the masses as mindless and sheeplike as possible...human cattle..Look back in history..you will find a common thread of sseemingly supernatual and absurd events/beliefs..ANyway this is going to take up oo much of the meagre amount of time i have left to play with words...so i'll just finish up by doubling back on myself:>
Where is this higher power you talk off???Whose God??Which God???And where are the xamples of Good and Evil seperated and labelled distincly enough for te world to take heed...????

Posted: Fri Mar 17, 2006 7:26 pm
by zERo~Chronic
what if, all the many forms of "god" that everyone worships, prays too, and lives their lives under, was actually evil itself, and maybe what everyone sees as evil is really the right thing to do, this might not make much sence to people but think about it

Posted: Fri Mar 17, 2006 11:16 pm
by weedguru_animal
its just too much for me to try look at the populace of earth as ALL beleivers as ALL worshippers....there is a huge amount of people with no belief in anything other than $$$$..maybe you could suggest that it is $$ that are the true evil..or one of the truest and most virulent evils amongst Life on the earth becaue it affects more people than religion...i mean everyone has to earn something to get by, but not everyone has to pray to/believe in/worship a divine force.....

Posted: Sat Mar 18, 2006 7:40 am
by zERo~Chronic
weedguru_animal wrote:its just too much for me to try look at the populace of earth as ALL beleivers as ALL worshippers....there is a huge amount of people with no belief in anything other than $$$$..maybe you could suggest that it is $$ that are the true evil..or one of the truest and most virulent evils amongst Life on the earth becaue it affects more people than religion...i mean everyone has to earn something to get by, but not everyone has to pray to/believe in/worship a divine force.....
thats true, but everyone has something, im sure no one just lives their lives like a robot, living every day like the last, with nothing to look foward too, for some people it may be god, others money, or for some of us weed or another form of intoxicating substances, really my point was just how do we know that good is good and evil is evil

Posted: Sat Mar 18, 2006 7:49 am
by Dr. Greenthumb
zERo~Chronic wrote:really my point was just how do we know that good is good and evil is evil
You know through your conscience and the way that your decisions effect other people.

Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 8:54 am
by Slim_Joules
Tokin42 wrote:
Slim, what you're proposing has been tried by many governments: fascism.
nah u dont get what i mean its like how can u be evil if you dont know evil
the same for good if there was no differentiation (i cant spell) between the good and evil could you do good and evil

Posted: Sun Apr 02, 2006 1:21 am
by Substance G
Sometimes I wonder... what if God is really the evil one... and he has convinced us that the Devil is bad. Maybe humans have been fooled this whole time!

Posted: Sun Apr 02, 2006 9:58 pm
by Darth Inhaler
I used to think that too...then I brought it up in church and I got kicked out.
True story.

Posted: Mon Apr 03, 2006 2:20 am
by canadianbud
Here is an interesting quote (i cant find the quote but its almost exactly like this) from jerry garcia.

EDIT: found the actual quote "What is life but being conscious? And good and evil are manifestations of consciousness. If you reject one, you're not getting the whole thing that's there to be had."

makes ya think.