free range V Organic (V biodynamic?)
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2006 1:35 am
organic-
Of, relating to, or derived from living organisms.
Using or produced with fertilizers of animal or vegetable matter, using no synthetic fertilizers or pesticides.
Free from chemical injections or additives, such as antibiotics or hormones.
free range-
: of livestock and domestic poultry; permitted to graze or forage rather than being confined to a feedlot
(NB I couldnt find a quick and adequate definition of BIODYNAMIC)
Okay, I have had this 'discussion' with a few freinds and strangers in the past, and it has often boiled into some kinda angry rant (on my part). When I was working as a fishmonger, I would question people who asked specifically for 'organic' fish, to try and ascertain whether health/moral/ethical reasons were behind their request. If the answer tended towards moral/ethical reasoning, I would attack with vigour and more rigorous questiong inre: how the hell can a fish be called organic, when it swims in the same sea as it's non-organic brethren, and its only main difference in lifestyle is the fact that it swims all its terribly small hours/days in the confinement of a pen(like a sea cage).
Thats just one example of an area which causes me much stress. I generally have this idea in my head, that FREE RANGE means 'good for the animal' and that ORGANIC means good for humans (primarily, as in not for animals I mean, as not sure what organic livestock food contains, like it would be dumb to feed animals organic feed which made them sick, then feel good about ourseleves for buying ORGANIC meat from a animal sympathizer perspective)).
ORGANIC for peoples benefit, FREE RANGE for animals benefit (also humans as meat would/does taste nicer than non-free range cousins).
Now my lady was trying to explain to me the idea of BIODYNAMIC meat, which I have started to understand as a label given to a farm or crop/livestock product, which has never had ANY contact from non-organic chemicals. I could do with more though.....????
another point that 'crops' up (dam, its impossible to put good puns in forum posts isnt it) in my mind, is of the food tha ORGANIC reared livestock is fed. like are they fed ORGANIC FEED which still makes them as profitable as possible, or does organic feed normally consist of the animals more traditional wild diet?
Anyway, I buy free range chicken more now, because I can kinda afford it, also free range eggs i buy regulalrly. For some reason ORGANIC food seems kinda selfish or maybe just sensible for those taking the utmost care of their bodies. selfish, is a word probably way off the mark, if allthe facts were known to me.
above all i am happy to support any measures which make will make the lives of animals, reared only for slaughter, easier and more natural (tho admittedly i find it hard to believe that the daily death, that wanders around farmyards like a law-endorsed genocidal maniac, does not fill most animals with dread. they arent stupid. but that is he start of another topic entirely, and one which I certainly dont wanna mix up with this fucker. another time, yeh, intelligence of animals/general non humam lifeforms, is something i find extremely interesting...
but what of you people, what are your thoughts on ORGANIC, FREE RANGE, BIODYNAMIC and MASS PRODUCED foodtypes?
DO you care??you dam well should, given the current farming situation, in which farmers are forced to squeeze as much out of each years products to survive, or to dream of competing with the monopolies that the biggst companies have in place...
Farmers cutting corners isnt good news for people who eat, bascially.
Anyway thats more than enough to bore all but the most stoned, who must lack the ability to change this screen....

Of, relating to, or derived from living organisms.
Using or produced with fertilizers of animal or vegetable matter, using no synthetic fertilizers or pesticides.
Free from chemical injections or additives, such as antibiotics or hormones.
free range-
: of livestock and domestic poultry; permitted to graze or forage rather than being confined to a feedlot
(NB I couldnt find a quick and adequate definition of BIODYNAMIC)
Okay, I have had this 'discussion' with a few freinds and strangers in the past, and it has often boiled into some kinda angry rant (on my part). When I was working as a fishmonger, I would question people who asked specifically for 'organic' fish, to try and ascertain whether health/moral/ethical reasons were behind their request. If the answer tended towards moral/ethical reasoning, I would attack with vigour and more rigorous questiong inre: how the hell can a fish be called organic, when it swims in the same sea as it's non-organic brethren, and its only main difference in lifestyle is the fact that it swims all its terribly small hours/days in the confinement of a pen(like a sea cage).
Thats just one example of an area which causes me much stress. I generally have this idea in my head, that FREE RANGE means 'good for the animal' and that ORGANIC means good for humans (primarily, as in not for animals I mean, as not sure what organic livestock food contains, like it would be dumb to feed animals organic feed which made them sick, then feel good about ourseleves for buying ORGANIC meat from a animal sympathizer perspective)).
ORGANIC for peoples benefit, FREE RANGE for animals benefit (also humans as meat would/does taste nicer than non-free range cousins).
Now my lady was trying to explain to me the idea of BIODYNAMIC meat, which I have started to understand as a label given to a farm or crop/livestock product, which has never had ANY contact from non-organic chemicals. I could do with more though.....????
another point that 'crops' up (dam, its impossible to put good puns in forum posts isnt it) in my mind, is of the food tha ORGANIC reared livestock is fed. like are they fed ORGANIC FEED which still makes them as profitable as possible, or does organic feed normally consist of the animals more traditional wild diet?
Anyway, I buy free range chicken more now, because I can kinda afford it, also free range eggs i buy regulalrly. For some reason ORGANIC food seems kinda selfish or maybe just sensible for those taking the utmost care of their bodies. selfish, is a word probably way off the mark, if allthe facts were known to me.
above all i am happy to support any measures which make will make the lives of animals, reared only for slaughter, easier and more natural (tho admittedly i find it hard to believe that the daily death, that wanders around farmyards like a law-endorsed genocidal maniac, does not fill most animals with dread. they arent stupid. but that is he start of another topic entirely, and one which I certainly dont wanna mix up with this fucker. another time, yeh, intelligence of animals/general non humam lifeforms, is something i find extremely interesting...
but what of you people, what are your thoughts on ORGANIC, FREE RANGE, BIODYNAMIC and MASS PRODUCED foodtypes?
DO you care??you dam well should, given the current farming situation, in which farmers are forced to squeeze as much out of each years products to survive, or to dream of competing with the monopolies that the biggst companies have in place...
Farmers cutting corners isnt good news for people who eat, bascially.
Anyway thats more than enough to bore all but the most stoned, who must lack the ability to change this screen....