Video card comparisons
Posted: Sun May 29, 2005 5:38 pm
Okay to begin with, I'm stoned.
Now that we have that out of the way, this is going to be a long topic...depending on if I get it all posted before my computer freezes again.
Here is something I bid on at eBay through my best friend's girlfriend's account. I won it just today about 10 minutes ago!! Here's the link to show you all the specs:
http://cgi.ebay.ca/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vie ... 5202109088
So that's an ATI Brand Radeon 9600 Pro 256 MB DDR. I bought it for $127 Canadian including the shipping. That card as an MSI brand, not ATI sells OEM at a local shoppe here for $138 plus 15% tax!
The card I currently have, which doesn't work at all for playing games because I think it's defective, is a Celestica Radeon 9600XT 128 MB DDR. Which card is better overall for gaming??
The reason I ask, is because my crappy card I can RMA through the company I bought it from locally. I bought it in January for $175.00 plus tax. So if the card I just won on eBay is better than the one I have now, I'll keep it. If the one that I am going to RMA is better, then I'll use my new card until the RMA comes back...which could be 2 to 6 weeks depending.
Basically, I'm confused. Specs always seem misleading sometimes. Also, I've heard from other computer people that when another manufacturer (like MSI, Celestica, Sapphire, ) makes a video card, they use cheaper boards and sometimes insufficient cooling.
The heatsink and cooling fan on this new card I won looks TONS better than what I have on my 9600XT. The only thing is has is a fan on GPU...no heatsink.
Anyhow, to sum up quickly here...what card is better?
The ATI 9600Pro
The Celestica 9600XT
Now that we have that out of the way, this is going to be a long topic...depending on if I get it all posted before my computer freezes again.
Here is something I bid on at eBay through my best friend's girlfriend's account. I won it just today about 10 minutes ago!! Here's the link to show you all the specs:
http://cgi.ebay.ca/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vie ... 5202109088
So that's an ATI Brand Radeon 9600 Pro 256 MB DDR. I bought it for $127 Canadian including the shipping. That card as an MSI brand, not ATI sells OEM at a local shoppe here for $138 plus 15% tax!
The card I currently have, which doesn't work at all for playing games because I think it's defective, is a Celestica Radeon 9600XT 128 MB DDR. Which card is better overall for gaming??
The reason I ask, is because my crappy card I can RMA through the company I bought it from locally. I bought it in January for $175.00 plus tax. So if the card I just won on eBay is better than the one I have now, I'll keep it. If the one that I am going to RMA is better, then I'll use my new card until the RMA comes back...which could be 2 to 6 weeks depending.
Basically, I'm confused. Specs always seem misleading sometimes. Also, I've heard from other computer people that when another manufacturer (like MSI, Celestica, Sapphire, ) makes a video card, they use cheaper boards and sometimes insufficient cooling.
The heatsink and cooling fan on this new card I won looks TONS better than what I have on my 9600XT. The only thing is has is a fan on GPU...no heatsink.
Anyhow, to sum up quickly here...what card is better?
The ATI 9600Pro
The Celestica 9600XT