Page 3 of 5
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Thu May 05, 2011 6:43 pm
by wgToonces
^Yeah he did take credit for the attacks..i.e. him saying "yup, it was me". But if someone was killed and I phoned the police and said it was me. I wouldn't just be thrown in jail, fuck even if I sent a video tape saying it was me that was responsible for the 9/11 attacks to the media, I would definetly not be shot in the head...There's procedures to find someone guilty etc. No procedure was even taken,there was no trial, it might not even have been him, but when you think about what the CIA are like and the American govt and how they love oil and how they NEED to perpetuate(?) and enemy...it all adds up.
Think about it, some guy in another country (a country where the govt made papers saying they wanted to invade for oil years before) "sends" a video tape in to America, and suddenly HES THE GUY WHO DID IT OMFGGGGGG...Get what I mean?? Sounds more like they put him there, and he was working with them, and when they didnt need him anymore, they got rid of him...Or he died a while ago and they just kept saying he was alive for as long as they needed him to be.
Bu then again, who knows man, it's all speculation at this point (probably at any point) unless you have top secret knowledge....But when you look at history, read between the lines, and think about everything that has happened...what the govt is saying just doesn't make sense or add up...I dunno.
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Fri May 06, 2011 2:13 am
by weedguru_animal
Ikku wrote:I too have seen documentaries and videos online demonstrating the massive amounts of uneducated people in America. It's not really a fair point though, and my experience living in America for 20 years doesn't support it. I'm sure in any country, you could find plenty of mindless twits to fill a documentary with. That doesn't say anything statistically about the American people. Whenever there's some data about some high percentage of Americans being unable to find Iraq on a map for instance, that's just data from some arbitrary survey, it's not rigorous statistical data screened for sampling bias. There are plenty of half wits living in the boonies and a portion of them have crept into our cities, but my experience with most people is nothing like what such surveys would suggest.
And internet access...technically almost 100% of Americans should have internet access, at least at public libraries. Three out of four households have internet access. While a lot of them aren't using it regularly or for news, but as the baby boomers are growing old and younger generations are taking the forefront, this is changing. And when some major story hits Wikileaks for example, the major news media outlets are compelled to report it, or else they will lose out in the market because other news stations will beat them to the story and people will turn to the outlets doing the most reporting. Capitalism + free information = very high chance of the public receiving that information because media outlets will compete to give people the most accurate and complete information.
Also, Fire Inside, you didn't address the fact that Osama took credit for the attacks. I'm not 100% sure that he did, but there is definitely more evidence that he did than you're letting on.
Only got time to respond to the first part of your welcome words, ikku, as i am on a quick dash home for lunch to release the hound from his bedroom holding cell, due to the builders repairing the house.
What I ommitted from my previous post, was that the vast majority of my opinions and perceptions of the US come from american writers. Who make up the bulk of my most commonly read authors of the last decade. Without doubt, I can speak mainly of england, next of australia, in terms of personal experiences IN those societies, but common threads are easily found throughout the writings of burroughs, bukowski, miller, thompson and chomsky (amongst others). Chomsky is the best one to read as he is the most objective, but still...i am well aware that Chomsky is nowhere near nationally respected in the US, and likely neither are the others. Still...the reputation of the americans having a very high, an inordinately high % of uneducated, dumb is shared by most of the known world. Reputations come about through a lot of factors, but its not me showing angst, or projecting my own perception onto the world. The reputation holds firm, regardless of my own views. A reputation confirmed when the commander in chief tells the world that saddam killed the mandelas...that simply wouldn't happen in England. Never. This was not in the slightest an isolated incident. For a man like Bush to be elected initially, then re-elected, can only be due to extreme deception on the part of the republicans, an electoral system extremely manipulated and in no way democratic...OR...vaste masses of uneducated, unaware people, who simply liked Bush, and felt he was the best man for the job.
I always add in that the majority of my favourite artists are american, the same can be said of my favourite actors and musicians. Its not an attack on the country I am making, its more a suggestion of how and why the government there can get away with what I perceive to be massively the greatest exporter of state sponsored terrorism, and for the people to seem to, at least in the majority, care very little, or actually find pride in such things...
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Fri May 06, 2011 1:07 pm
by cutthecashflow
I had a nice, long, elaborate post on this issue, but I lost connection when submitting and it was lost. I shall return to the fray when I am in front of a pc again and not my Droid. Probably two to three days.
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Sat May 07, 2011 9:41 am
by weedguru_animal
cutthecashflow wrote:I had a nice, long, elaborate post on this issue, but I lost connection when submitting and it was lost. I shall return to the fray when I am in front of a pc again and not my Droid. Probably two to three days.
i look forward to an expression of your stance, mate...as i sit here and smile, darkly, at how the US is reporting the incident...patronising, at best, to anyone with a half functioning mind. The US army chap speaking moments ago was saying 'we found him, told him to stand down, he resisted, used his wife as a human shield, and we shot him in the head...he clearly steers well clear in his reality than he does in his narrative, living in a million dollar home far away from the front line'...well...he appears to have been staying, literally a stone throw from a pakistani training base for new army recruits. now THAT is truly mocking the americans...
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Mon May 09, 2011 10:00 am
by weedquotes
maybe if Osama would have smoked a bit of weed from time to time, things wouldn't have turned so ugly for him..check out what Gil Kopatch has to say about weed and islam : "You know, there are around a million Israelis who smoke this stuff. You know how much this costs me? Loads. And do you know who grows and produces this? Hamas and Hezbollah. Yes, David. As defense minister, it is important that you know this. They're making piles of money off of us. They take the money and buy kassams to fire at us. A pity, no? Why shouldn't it be legal? You see, if it'll be legal, we could grow it here on these arid Negev hills, make the wilderness flower. We will keep the money in Israel and use it for good causes, David, like raising the teachers' salaries... The question is, though, what will Hamas and Hezbollah do with all the hashish they'll be left with? The answer is simple: They'll smoke it. They'll smoke it, David, and be calm. Because a good Arab is a calm Arab. And this, is my security concept"
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Mon May 09, 2011 6:35 pm
by Ikku
^You smell kind of like spam but I really like your post.
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Mon May 09, 2011 7:49 pm
by andriaSRH
Yeaaa I really liked the "Because a good Arab is a calm Arab" part ...lol ...but the link in the sig screams bot.
(weedguru)scarf wrote:It was watched live by white house staff, so surely there is video proving death...
i assume they will eventually release it
Dontcha think they would have done that already? We videotapped Saddam Hussein being hung..but ohhh they just dump Bin Ladens body in the ocean like he is Megatron? I'm not buying it.
I watched an animated reinactment of the events..apparently one of the Seals took a picture to send to the Obama to confirm it was Bin Laden. We're talking about public Enemy Number One..."the real picture" should have been shown to us. The world watched thousands of people die on 9/11...it just doesn't make sense that we didn't even get to see them throw his ass into the sea.
This whole situation is most likely going to always remain a mystery.
Maybe this thread should be moved to Mass Debate? 0.o
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Mon May 09, 2011 8:17 pm
by Ikku
It sure is puzzling why no photos or videos have been released. Makes me think they faked it and at the same time makes me think they didn't fake it. It would be really easy to release fake photos/videos and get away with it, show the world any old, raggedy looking desert Muslim and they'd believe it was him, especially since don't they shave Muslims before burial? At that point he might not be recognizable at all.
On the other hand, they might know that conspiracy theorists would just try to prove the videos/photos were fake even if they are real, and so it's basically their prerogative whether or not they release anything since people will call BS no matter what they do.
EDIT: Thinking a little more, I still lean toward the idea that this story is fake. If it were real they wouldn't have to be careful at all what evidence they release since it's going to be real evidence, and they can just release everything. If it's fake, they have to be careful not to release anything that will just give it away. Like that supposed leaked photo of a dead Bin Laden that turned out to be fake, maybe that "leak" was just a covert "release" to test the waters and when it was proven fake almost immediately, they decided to hedge their bets and not release anything else.
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 9:21 am
by weedguru_animal
andriaSRH wrote:Yeaaa I really liked the "Because a good Arab is a calm Arab" part ...lol ...but the link in the sig screams bot.
(weedguru)scarf wrote:It was watched live by white house staff, so surely there is video proving death...
i assume they will eventually release it
Dontcha think they would have done that already? We videotapped Saddam Hussein being hung..but ohhh they just dump Bin Ladens body in the ocean like he is Megatron?
I'm not buying it. I watched an animated reinactment of the events..apparently one of the Seals took a picture to send to the Obama to confirm it was Bin Laden. We're talking about public Enemy Number One..."the real picture" should have been shown to us. The world watched thousands of people die on 9/11...it just doesn't make sense that we didn't even get to see them throw his ass into the sea.
This whole situation is most likely going to always remain a mystery.
Maybe this thread should be moved to Mass Debate? 0.o
The spirit I know lies vibrant in few, latent in many, is awakening from its slumber...

Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 12:49 pm
by Weedguru_Fire_Inside
wgToonces wrote:^Yeah he did take credit for the attacks..i.e. him saying "yup, it was me".
Can somebody prove this for me? i saw the footage bin laden released while in hiding, but none of the videos i have seen show him taking credit for the attacks in this manner. In the footage released by 'bin laden', there is still controversy over whether it was even bin laden or not.
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 4:40 pm
by sugarstalker
there still isn't any proof he was involved at all in the planning, as has been said, just saying "hay gusy! I did it" would not hold up. atleast not in an international court.
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 5:42 pm
by wgToonces
Weedguru_Fire_Inside wrote:wgToonces wrote:^Yeah he did take credit for the attacks..i.e. him saying "yup, it was me".
Can somebody prove this for me? i saw the footage bin laden released while in hiding, but none of the videos i have seen show him taking credit for the attacks in this manner. In the footage released by 'bin laden', there is still controversy over whether it was even bin laden or not.
Well I'm sure there was a video of him taking credit for the attacks, but I've been looking into this a lot recently and it may not even have been him.
This website addresses some good questions about the whole thing.
http://www.opednews.com/articles/OSAMA- ... 2-107.html
Perhaps the biggest outstanding question about his role in the 9/11 attacks is: Why would the U.S. Defense Department have produced a phony "smoking gun" video in a blatantly false attempt to claim that bin Laden masterminded the 9/11 attacks? On December 13, 2001, U.S. Defense Secretary, Donald Rumsfeld released, without comment, a video that later appeared on C-Span. The origination has never been published but some think that the video came from his Office of Defense Policy, headed by Doug Feith. In that video, a man who Americans were led to believe was Osama Bin Laden, indicated that he had foreknowledge of the 9/11 attacks. But there is just one problem. The man in the video was obviously not Osama Bin Laden. Check out the pictures below of him from that video compared to other authenticated sources taken just before and after that time.
That Defense Department video was widely used to label Osama bin Laden as the mastermind of 9/11 even though bin Laden consistently denied involvement in authenticated Arab sources such as Al Jazeera. Years later, President George W. Bush admitted that bin Laden was not the mastermind after his administration obtained a confession from Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. That confession came in 2007, after Mohammed was waterboarded and subject to a variety of other torture treatments prior to the coerced confession
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 8:18 pm
by SToNeR ChRiS
Ugh two times in a row now that my post gets deleted after I want to submit it... bullshit. The other day I had a written out post as well which then got deleted. I decided to rewrite it but then decided against submitting it. It was clear to me, that there were people on both sides of the debate who simply wouldn't change their stance. People keep saying that there is no proof that Bin Laden specifically was responsibly for the attacks themselves. But at the same time, there simply is no proof that he was not the one responsible for the attacks... so to each their own. On a personal level, the incidents which transpired on September 11th are rooted in a deeper history than that day itself. It all started with the Cold War and the United States' relations with Afghanistan. Sure, there may not be any proof that Bin Laden gave the
direct orders to the highjackers on the day of September 11th. With that being said, after conducting some research on the history of freedom fighters and their perception of the west, as well as the United States' past history with Afghanistan and other middle eastern nations, once again to me, it shows that Al Qaida and Bin Laden were the most
likely to be responsible for the attacks. In addition, Bin Laden was Al Qaida's leader at the time, so whether or not he gave the direct orders or not is actually a moot point in my books. Bin Laden may have never openly stated "I, Osama Bin Laden conducted the attacks", however he shared knowledge about why the attacks, specifically on the towers, were initially inspired and acted upon. If he was simply being a phony and taking responsibilty for something he was not responsible for then I believe he deserved the same fate he received anyway...
As for the post I was going to submit the other day here it is...
Ahh I had already written a post in response to you AFI, but it got deleted! With that being said, it is clear that any piece of evidence I show will be put into question. You have already made your mind up on one end of the spectrum and frankly I do not care whether or not your opinion changes... that's up to you. I have never said anything about proof holding up in a court of law, because as I'm sure you are aware, many nations have already stated that there simply would not have been enough evidence to convinct Bin Laden in a court of law. This does not stop me from using my own mind and taking evidence for what it is to draw some sort of conclusion. While I'm doing all the work here, what is your proof for the other side of the debate? All I constantly hear is discussion of the United States' past history of deceit and not telling the whole truth... This is simply not good enough and would be an incredibly weak counter-argument in a court of law as well.
As for my point, which could indeed be considered coincidental in a court of law, does it not at all change your perspective on the likelihood that Al Qaeda may have been responsible? Perhaps you do not understand who Massoud was and what he represented? Massoud was the leader of the more legitimate Northern Alliance in Afghanistan. Only weeks before the acts of September 11th he had publically warned the United States of such attacks. Then,two days prior to September 11th, he was assassinated by the first ever suicide bombing in Afghanistan. Now, the individual who the United States would have turned to in a time of crisis was eliminated. In addition, the Taliban and other terrorist groups now controlled most of the nation. Finally it WAS proven that Al Qaeda was responsible for the attacks on Massoud. I do not see the point in adding any more facts to prove my point, because they will certainly be refuted by non-believers. Even when I show a video where Bin Laden openly admits to being at the very least inspirationally responsible for the attacks it is dismissed at the snap of a finger and deemed "fake". I am not here to change your mind, I am simply here to state my opinion. Basically all other facts I could bring up such as Al Qaeda members receiving a large amount of flight training have already been beaten to death... and I'm CERTAIN you've already debated any point I could bring up in the 10 years since the event. If you'd like some more food for thought, however, Al Qaeda are the only terrorist group in the world who use suicide attacks as their NUMBER 1 strategy when it comes to terrorist activities.
In the end, I agree that it is IMPOSSIBLE, with the information provided to know for certain that Bin Laden was the individual who directly commanded the acts of September 11th. At the VERY LEAST however, he was the leader of the group who certainly did commit the acts. Al Qaeda is an international terrorist group with citizens from dozens of nations taking part in their terrorist activities. At the time of the attacks, he was their LEADER. Who should one target in such a situation? There is only one answer, Bin Laden.
The very fact that people are bringing up conspiracy theories about two entirely different events proves that people on here either smoke too much weed (as they should) and are extremely paranoid, or that they simply dismiss EVERY SINGLE account provided by the United States' government. This thread is about the fact that Bin Laden was killed, not even about whether or not he was responsible for the attacks themselves... and look what we're discussing.
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Wed May 11, 2011 5:38 am
by Ikku
Good points sir.
Re: osama bin laden DEAD
Posted: Wed May 11, 2011 12:53 pm
by Weedguru_Fire_Inside
A couple of good points. You're very, very right in saying my opinion will not change because of what you put. My opinion will only change when something is absolutely proven to me.
I, personally, cannot show you any hard evidence that it was not Al Quaida, but i can show you more compelling evidence that it was an act of the American Government, rather than Al Quaida. But, having done a university course in terrorism, i assume you've already seen it.
When you say it was proven that Al Quaida were responsible for the attacks, can you prove this for me? I'm not trying to say you're bullshitting, but this would genuinely be a vital piece of information i missed out on, if it's true.
Other than that, i'm out of this "debate". It's hardly productive and it just pisses me right off.